A US federal appeals court docket on Wednesday rejected claims by Apple prospects that the iPhone maker gave them much less iCloud knowledge storage than they paid for when upgrading.
In a 3-0 resolution, the ninth US Circuit Courtroom of Appeals in San Francisco mentioned affordable customers within the proposed class motion wouldn’t have been misled by Apple’s guarantees about storage capability in its iCloud+ plans.
The plaintiff Lisa Bodenburg mentioned she paid $2.99 a month for 200 GB of storage, believing Apple would add it to the 5 GB that every one iCloud prospects obtain, and was shortchanged as a result of Apple gave her solely 200 GB of whole storage, not 205 GB.
Circuit Choose Milan Smith, nevertheless mentioned Bodenburg “obtained precisely what Apple promised her” when the Cupertino, California-based firm provided “incremental” or “supplemental” storage, on prime of the 5 GB she acquired totally free.
He cited dismissals of different circumstances based mostly on “unreasonable assumptions,” together with that Food regimen Dr. Pepper would help in weight reduction, and the web weight on a lip balm label didn’t reveal that the dispenser’s design left some balm inaccessible.
“Apple’s statements aren’t false and misleading merely as a result of [they] could also be unreasonably misunderstood by an insignificant and unrepresentative section of customers,” Smith wrote.
Attorneys for Bodenburg didn’t instantly reply to requests for remark. The choice upheld a Could 2024 dismissal by US District Choose Trina Thompson in San Francisco.
© Thomson Reuters 2025